One of them had a chip missing on the top

Seem solid, easy to install. Pay attention to the dimensions so you won't be disappointed. I needed these to be black so ended up painting them. The finish is quite slick so if you do paint you should sand and prime or use 2 coats of paint(which is what I did). Came out looking great! I am using them as a window scarf holder.

Just as expected, love the color and easy installation.

Heavier than I expected, but just what I needed.