These are great! Super beautifully finished and the sturdy metal that they slid onto makes sure they aren’t going anywhere once mounted. I couldn’t recommend these more! They are a nice size and smooth as butter

Let me start with the positive: I like the color and that is made of solid wood and the gluing looks good. The problem I have is their quality control and post-staining/painting process but pre packaging at the factory. There are several very noticeable scratch marks on both boards and one of them has a very noticeable scratch on the edge facing out. There was a what looked to have been dust settling on the wood before they painted, because it came right off. There was padding in the packaging so my best guess it was from the factory. I feel fine getting by with using the least visibly damaged of the two shelves, but I think they just need to be sanded and restained but that is not what you want after getting something new.

Look great