4 stars only because a double roll of toilet paper is a very tight squeeze, so I’d recommend standard size rolls. Otherwise, these are great! The toilet paper roll stays on the holder and it is very solid and sturdy. The black finish does not scratch and brings a fresh modern look!

They came in handy since I have two bathrooms and I really needed them . The toilet tissue was always on the countertop and I was getting frustrated since it was always getting wet. They are sturdy and better than the ones I had before

This toliet paper holder is exactly what I wanted and needed. It was easy to install. It doesn't set far from the wall and putting on the toliet paper roll is easy. The black color fits right in with my bathroom decor.

I love this handle, it was easy to install and it added a modern flair to the bathroom. There was no toilet paper holder and this was the perfect addition. It will match perfectly with the other black components I am installing.

Haven’t put these up but they seem to be solid. It would be cool if they came with some sort of directions but it was just the holders and the hardware in the box. There are some extra steps that seem unnecessary so we will see how they actually hold up. They’re not something I’d purchase again but they’re for my office so they’ll do.