Little shorter than what I thought an "extra long" was.

It is durable and the length is great. Width was to wide.

OK at best. Not very weighty and the holes for the shower curtain rings are not reinforced enough to prevent tearing through them. Some holes are already compromised after only a few uses. Our liner and curtain are hung on a double rod, so opening and closing the liner is independent from the curtain. My point - opening and closing the curtain does not put undue stress on the liner. Opening and closing the liner is enough to eventually tear through the holes. I only bought these (2) because I needed the 84” length and couldn’t find them anywhere locally. I would not buy again.